January 29, 2006

A Kilt Is Not A Skirt

I had wanted to leave this as a comment over at Professor Althouse's site, but I don't have (or can't remember) a blogger ID. So, I am just going to post this here. This comes from reading about a rather clueless dweeb attacking Sonia Belle on her site, and an afternoon perusal of Althouse to see what all was there beside the message that set off the morality police. Here is the comment that could not be left:

A couple of quick points. First, a kilt is not technically a skirt, and only the ill-informed (or bigoted), or someone really trying to start something, call them that. :) There is a really old and bad joke about it being called a kilt because the last person to call it a skirt got kilt...

While Craig is technically correct (and I agree with him on the regimental tie issue), the fact is that general usage today has people wearing tartans they like no matter what. Personally, I like the tartan(s) of my primary clan, but I also don't blow a gasket if I see someone else wearing it who is not related. In point of fact, many clan societies will try to get them to join if they like it so much, as an associate or similar member. I don't recognize the tartan he is wearing, but will also point out that there are a number of regional, city, or other tartans which can be worn by those not in a clan.

I would also ask Craig how he arrived at wearing proper automatically becoming indecent exposure? That comes across much more as a cheap shot than anything.

And, I fear that the following will forever ban me from being blogrolled:

I am a descendent of Duncan, slain by the traitor MacBeth.

Fountain pens at dawn?

LW

Posted by wolf1 at January 29, 2006 10:19 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Heh - I'm from a Stuart offshoot. But I don't pay much attention to the old rivalries. Is my fountain pen beside you or agin you?

Posted by: http://site-essential.com at January 30, 2006 12:03 AM

LOL! I think we were mostly allies. Besides, I always want your fountain pen at my side.

Posted by: Laughing Wolf at January 30, 2006 12:44 AM

Hey, Woolfie!

Thanks for calling him a "clueless dweeb"... He deserved that!

Posted by: Sonia Belle at January 30, 2006 04:33 PM

... my grandmother was Dutch...

... got hitched in a kilt, though...

Posted by: Eric at January 30, 2006 09:29 PM

Being an individual that is painfully obvious with pride in his Scottish heritage. I've run the gambit of all the kilt wearing comments and insults. I used to wear one to work all the time, because we were a diverse company. Well that was BS because I took some serious ribbing over it. However, if I made the comment that someone wearing traditional African garb was wearing a mumu (sp?) I'd have gotten in trouble. The orriginal issue was just stupid.

As for the tartan issue. Being loyal to my Scottish decent and a Jacobite I refuse to recognize the tartan system. It's a Victorian English creation. The orriginal tartans were regional AND wealthy chieftans would wear many different tartans at the same time (Kilt, diamond toes, sash, coat, etc) to show they had money and could afford it.

Posted by: Contagion at January 31, 2006 01:57 AM

I like the MacInnes Hunting myself. Also the McLean and Graham. I have shades of all three, plus a great-uncle by marriage that was a Cameron. Quite a colorful combination.

Posted by: jlb at February 1, 2006 12:29 AM

Hell, I'm Irish. I think that speaks for itself.

And no, I'm not skirting the issue. ;)

Posted by: Dana at February 1, 2006 01:08 PM

I reckon you will be pleased to learn that my wee wifey is descended from Macduff, who avenged your forebear's slaying.

Posted by: triticale at February 5, 2006 04:11 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?